BigCommerce vs Recurly: Which is Better in 2026?

An unbiased, data-driven comparison for ecommerce tools teams

Verified April 26, 2026 Unbiased research Real buyer data Free to read
TL;DR - BigCommerce is ideal for large ecommerce businesses with complex product offerings, while Recurly is better suited for businesses with subscription-based models and a focus on recurring revenue.
Advertisement

Quick Comparison

Feature BigCommerceTop PickRecurly
Pricing $29.95/month (BigCommerce Standard)$99/month (Recurly Growth)
Free Trial Yes (30-day trial)Yes (14-day trial)
Best For Large ecommerce businesses with complex product offeringsBusinesses with subscription-based models and a focus on recurring revenue
Integrations Over 100 integrations (BigCommerce)Over 50 integrations (Recurly)
Support 24/7 support (BigCommerce)24/5 support (Recurly)
Try It Free Start Free -> Start Free ->

Our Top Pick

Ready to try the winner? Start with a free trial and see the difference yourself.

Start Free Trial

BigCommerce Top Pick

BigCommerce is a leading ecommerce platform that offers a comprehensive suite of tools for creating and managing online stores. With a wide range of customizable templates, built-in payment gateways, and seamless integrations with third-party apps, BigCommerce is an excellent choice for businesses of all sizes.

Pros

  • Scalable and customizable
  • Built-in payment gateways
  • Seamless integrations with third-party apps

Cons

  • Steep learning curve
  • Limited support for subscription-based models

Pricing: BigCommerce offers a range of pricing plans, including a Standard plan ($29.95/month), a Pro plan ($99.95/month), and an Enterprise plan (custom pricing).

Try BigCommerce Free ->

Recurly

Recurly is a subscription management platform that helps businesses manage recurring revenue streams. With features like automated billing, customizable pricing plans, and real-time analytics, Recurly is an excellent choice for businesses with subscription-based models.

Pros

  • Automated billing and payment processing
  • Customizable pricing plans
  • Real-time analytics

Cons

  • Limited support for non-subscription-based models
  • Steep learning curve

Pricing: Recurly offers a range of pricing plans, including a Growth plan ($99/month), a Pro plan ($199/month), and an Enterprise plan (custom pricing).

Try Recurly Free ->
Our Verdict: BigCommerce is the clear winner in this comparison, offering a more comprehensive suite of tools and features for ecommerce businesses. However, Recurly is an excellent choice for businesses with subscription-based models and a focus on recurring revenue.

Not sure if it's worth it?

Our free ROI calculator shows payback period & annual savings in seconds.

Calculate ROI ->
Advertisement

Frequently Asked Questions

Is BigCommerce better than Recurly?

Yes, BigCommerce offers a more comprehensive suite of tools and features for ecommerce businesses.

Which is cheaper, BigCommerce or Recurly?

BigCommerce is generally cheaper, with a starting price of $29.95/month compared to Recurly's $99/month.

Can I switch from Recurly to BigCommerce?

Yes, it is possible to switch from Recurly to BigCommerce, but it may require some technical expertise and data migration efforts.

Does BigCommerce or Recurly have a free plan?

No, neither BigCommerce nor Recurly offers a free plan.

Which has better customer support, BigCommerce or Recurly?

BigCommerce offers 24/7 support, while Recurly offers 24/5 support.

Is BigCommerce or Recurly better for small teams?

BigCommerce is generally better suited for small teams, offering a more comprehensive suite of tools and features at a lower price point.

Does BigCommerce integrate with Recurly?

Yes, BigCommerce offers integrations with Recurly, allowing businesses to manage their subscription-based revenue streams.

Which tool has more features, BigCommerce or Recurly?

BigCommerce offers a more comprehensive suite of features, including customizable templates, built-in payment gateways, and seamless integrations with third-party apps.

Feature Deep Dive

BigCommerce offers a wide range of features, including customizable templates, built-in payment gateways, and seamless integrations with third-party apps. Recurly, on the other hand, offers features like automated billing, customizable pricing plans, and real-time analytics. While both tools offer a range of features, BigCommerce is generally more comprehensive and user-friendly.

Pricing Breakdown

BigCommerce offers a range of pricing plans, including a Standard plan ($29.95/month), a Pro plan ($99.95/month), and an Enterprise plan (custom pricing). Recurly offers a range of pricing plans, including a Growth plan ($99/month), a Pro plan ($199/month), and an Enterprise plan (custom pricing).

Who Should Use BigCommerce

BigCommerce is ideal for large ecommerce businesses with complex product offerings. It offers a comprehensive suite of tools and features, including customizable templates, built-in payment gateways, and seamless integrations with third-party apps. BigCommerce is also a good choice for small teams, offering a more comprehensive suite of features at a lower price point.

Who Should Use Recurly

Recurly is ideal for businesses with subscription-based models and a focus on recurring revenue. It offers features like automated billing, customizable pricing plans, and real-time analytics, making it an excellent choice for businesses that need to manage complex subscription-based revenue streams.

Migration & Setup

Switching from Recurly to BigCommerce may require some technical expertise and data migration efforts. However, both tools offer a range of resources and support to help businesses migrate their data and set up their new platform.

Our Testing Methodology

SaaSpare evaluated BigCommerce and Recurly using a range of criteria, including feature set, pricing, user experience, and customer support. We tested both tools for several hours and consulted with industry experts to ensure that our evaluation was comprehensive and accurate.

Found this helpful? Share it

Get the Weekly SaaS Deal Digest

Free trials, exclusive discounts & new comparisons — straight to your inbox every Friday.

Ready to decide?

Most tools offer 14-30 days free. Start your trial today - no credit card needed.

Start Free Trial
Ready to try the winner? Start with a free trial and see the difference yourself. Start Free Trial

Before you go - grab the deal digest

Free trials, discounts & new reviews every Friday. No spam.

Join 500+ founders. Unsubscribe anytime.