TL;DR Quick Answer
Surfshark wins overall, scoring 9.1/10 in our editorial scoring. Choose Surfshark for Unlimited devices. Choose Private Internet Access for teams already invested in its ecosystem. Both offer risk-free trials.
Surfshark
Surfshark
Unlimited devices, best value VPN
Score: 9.1/10
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access, B2B SaaS tool
Score: 8.5/10
Winner
Our Verdict
Surfshark
Best for most users, see why below
→ Read our reasoning
SurfsharkVPN · from $2.19/mo
Unlimited devices, best value VPN. Best suited for teams that need unlimited devices, best value vpn.
Private Internet AccessSoftware · from From $0/mo
Private Internet Access, B2B SaaS tool. Best suited for teams that need private internet access, b2b saas tool.
Verdict at a Glance
Both tools solve real problems in the VPN category. Surfshark ($2.19/mo) is designed for Unlimited devices. Private Internet Access (From $0/mo) is built for Private Internet Access, B2B SaaS tool.
For most teams, Surfshark is the better starting point, both offer risk-free trials so you can verify this yourself before committing.
Pricing Comparison
| Plan | Surfshark | Private Internet Access |
| Starting price | $2.19/mo | From $0/mo |
| Free plan / trial | 30-day money-back | Trial available |
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Surfshark | Private Internet Access |
| Category | VPN | Software |
| Starting price | $2.19/mo | From $0/mo |
| Free tier | 30-day money-back | Trial available |
| Overall score | 9.1/10 | 8.5/10 |
Our Final Verdict
Surfshark is our recommendation for most users. Here is why:
- Choose Surfshark if your priority is Unlimited devices. Starting at $2.19/mo, with 30-day money-back.
- Choose Private Internet Access if you need Private Internet Access, B2B SaaS tool. Starting at From $0/mo, with Trial available.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Surfshark better than Private Internet Access?
Yes, Surfshark scores 9.1/10 vs Private Internet Access's 8.5/10 in our editorial scoring. Surfshark is better for Unlimited devices. Private Internet Access is the better choice if teams already invested in its ecosystem.
How much does Surfshark cost vs Private Internet Access?
Surfshark starts at $2.19/mo. Private Internet Access starts at From $0/mo. Both offer trial periods: Surfshark (30-day money-back), Private Internet Access (Trial available).
Can I try Surfshark and Private Internet Access for free?
Surfshark: 30-day money-back. Private Internet Access: Trial available. We recommend trialling both before committing.
What is Surfshark best for?
Surfshark is best for Unlimited devices, best value VPN. It's particularly strong for teams in the VPN category.